Skip to main content

Climate Emotions: Helpless Or Hopeful?

by Heidi Zamzow, April 17 2019

With the recent IPCC warning that we may have perhaps a dozen years before we encounter severe and irreversible impacts of climate change, it comes as little surprise that a recent survey* in climate communications research indicates 7 in 10 people in the U.S. are concerned about global warming, with a third of them “very worried.”  About half of those surveyed have personally experienced its effects in their own lives and believe others in the US are being harmed as well.

As science communicators, we may have had years to consider the catastrophic consequences of global warming. But for those who are just beginning to realize that “this is real, this is now”, what are the psychological impacts?

The same survey* indicated that people are more or less evenly split between feeling helpless and feeling hopeful. I encountered similar attitudes when I recently participated in a focus group with other students at The London School of Economics and Political Science, where we explored the ways we connect with and see ourselves in relationship with nature. It didn’t take long for the conversation to turn to climate change. Participants reported feeling overwhelmed, frightened and uncertain, but at the same time they felt a deep responsibility to future generations and to other species.

The good news is that, as climate communicators, our work is having a clear impact: Yale and George Mason University researchers* found that a significant portion of those who have changed their mind about climate change have done so because they have become more informed and are taking this challenge more seriously. However, we also need to be aware of the different ways individuals may be processing what could be new and frightening information.

So how do we convey the significance and urgency of climate change in a way that will leave our audience hopeful and inspired to act, rather than overwhelmed and discouraged? Fortunately, the behavioral science-based communications resources developed by Frameworks Institute and taught through the National Network for Ocean and Climate Change Interpretation (NNOCCI) provide critical insight.

When we use shared values like “protection” or “responsible management” as the lens through which we approach this topic, we keep the narrative focused on why action matters and help to prime a civic mindset that encourages people to think as citizens. Acting together, we can support community-level solutions that are bigger, bolder, and more meaningful than what any one of us could accomplish alone.

As communicators, we can encourage engagement behaviors that will help our audiences connect with other likeminded people in their community. We can also use specific examples of the impacts we’ve already seen from inspirational environmental movements, both past and present, to help people understand how our actions today can have a lasting impact on generations to come. Starting these values-based, solutions-focused conversations spreads the hope we need for swift and effective climate action in our communities.   

*Summarized in the December 2018 report “Climate Change in the American Mind” as part of a decade-long joint study by the Yale Program on Climate Change Communication and Center for Climate Change Communications at George Mason University

Generic selectors
Exact matches only
Search in title
Search in content
Post Type Selectors

More Blog Posts

  • Friendly neighborhood climate scientist
    Friendly neighborhood climate scientist by Jeremy Owens, March 23 2020  Have you ever wanted or even needed a climate science question answered but couldn’t find an answer and you wanted to speak with a scientist? Have you wanted to work with a scientist to do outreach but didn’t know how to contact someone? If you have ever had a need but felt [READ MORE]
  • Underwater kelp forest in WashingtonFrom Course to Conversation: A Climate Story on Kelp Forests
    As part of NNOCCI’s 7-week Crash Course, participants learn to tell powerful climate stories using science-based strategic framing tools, such as values, metaphors, and solutions. From riding public transit to supporting clean energy, the choices we make near and far from shore can protect ocean ecosystems. One participant turned this message into a climate story to spark conversation about kelp forests — paired with her whimsical underwater photography.[READ MORE]
  • Two men stand on a sea wallTo Frame Climate Change, Lead with a Researched Value—Not a “Rogue” One
    To Frame Climate Change, Lead with a Researched Value—Not a “Rogue” One January 20 2017 This is the sixth post in a series about framing ocean and climate change. So, you want to motivate the public to take action to address climate and ocean change? One of the most important communications moves you can make is to open with a broad statement [READ MORE]
  • Communicating in the Swamp: How to Navigate Public Thinking About Climate and Ocean Change
    Communicating in the Swamp: How to Navigate Public Thinking About Climate and Ocean Change July 22 2016  This is the first in a series about framing ocean and climate change. When people think about oceans this summer, they might think of a good vacation spot—a place to spread out the beach towel, pop up the umbrella, and relax under the sun as [READ MORE]
  • Thinking Bigger On Solutions
    Thinking Bigger On Solutions by Allison Arteaga, February 28 2020 We all know that we need big, systems-level change in our society in order to address climate change and create a better future. This requires high-impact collective actions that create change at the cultural and public levels by bringing people together (Frameworks). The challenge [READ MORE]